Best Criminal Podcast Alternatives ranked by AI · updated Aug 2026

Criminal is an investigative true-crime podcast hosted by Phoebe Judge and produced by Radiotopia. It examines unusual crimes, legal cases, and the people affected by them through carefully reported standalone episodes.

Developer: Radiotopia Price: Free 🎯 thisiscriminal.com

Storytelling Podcast true crime investigative

Top 6 Criminal Podcast alternatives

Crime Junkie

audiochuck

💡 Pick it for more frequent episodes and a stronger focus on missing-person and unsolved cases.

Crime Junkie is a weekly true-crime podcast hosted by Ashley Flowers and produced by audiochuck. It presents cases involving missing people, unsolved...

Pros

More frequent releases than Criminal
Strong focus on missing-person and unsolved cases
Large back catalog and active listener community

Cons

More conversational and less restrained than Criminal
Some listeners may prefer deeper sourcing and reporting
Recurring format can feel less varied

Free; optional paid membership

Alternatives to Crime Junkie → Visit site

My Favorite Murder

Exactly Right Media

💡 Pick it if you want true crime with substantial host banter, comedy, and listener-community interaction.

My Favorite Murder is a true-crime comedy podcast hosted by Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark. It combines researched crime stories with personal...

Pros

More humor and host banter than Criminal
Extensive episode archive covering varied cases
Frequent listener-submitted stories and community interaction

Cons

Less formal and less journalistic than Criminal
Comedy may not suit sensitive cases or every listener
Episodes can be longer and more conversational

Free; optional paid membership

Alternatives to My Favorite Murder → Visit site

Serial

💡 Pick it for deep, season-long investigations instead of Criminal's mostly standalone stories.

Serial is a powerful software tool for managing serial numbers and product keys.

$99.99

Alternatives to Serial → Visit site

Casefile

Casefile Presents

💡 Pick it for darker, more detailed case timelines and broad international coverage.

Casefile is an anonymous-hosted true-crime podcast covering solved and unsolved cases from around the world. It uses a serious, documentary-style narration with...

Pros

More detailed chronology and case documentation than Criminal
Covers international cases that many U.S.-focused shows omit
Consistent serious tone without comedy

Cons

More graphic and emotionally intense than Criminal
Anonymous narration offers less host personality
Long episodes can feel dense for casual listeners

Free; optional paid membership

Alternatives to Casefile → Visit site

Someone Knows Something

CBC

💡 Pick it for compassionate, season-long field investigations into unresolved cases.

Someone Knows Something is a CBC investigative podcast hosted by David Ridgen that revisits unresolved disappearances and killings. Each season follows a...

Pros

More intimate field reporting than Criminal
Focuses closely on families and unresolved cases
CBC reporting provides a strong public-broadcasting framework

Cons

Fewer new seasons than regularly scheduled crime podcasts
Requires sequential listening within each season
Pacing is slower than Crime Junkie or Casefile

Free

Alternatives to Someone Knows Some... → Visit site

Swindled

A Concerned Citizen

💡 Pick it for corporate scandals, fraud, and corruption rather than conventional murder cases.

Swindled is a documentary-style podcast about white-collar crime, fraud, corruption, and corporate wrongdoing. It uses a deadpan anonymous narration style and archival...

Pros

More specialized coverage of fraud and corporate crime than Criminal
Distinctive deadpan narration and archival research
Explains financial scandals in accessible terms

Cons

Narrower subject range than Criminal
Less focus on victims' personal narratives
Anonymous host provides limited conversational interaction

Free; optional paid membership

Alternatives to Swindled → Visit site

How good are these alternatives?

Your feedback helps us improve the AI rankings.

✅ Thanks for your feedback!

Know a better alternative? 🙌

Suggest a product and our AI will verify it's a real alternative to Criminal Podcast before adding it to the list.

People also compare

🔎 KeyGenius 🔎 LicenseMaster 🔎 KeyTrack