Best Progressive Alternatives ranked by AI · updated Aug 2026

✅ Update queued — the AI is re-ranking this list. The page will refresh shortly.

This page is already up to date.

Progressive offers motorcycle insurance for riders across the United States, with liability, collision, comprehensive, and optional accessory coverage. It combines broad policy availability with online quoting and established claims infrastructure.

Developer: Progressive Corporation Price: Quote-based 🎯 progressive.com

💻 Online Services 💼 Insurance auto insurance motorcycle insurance

Top 6 Progressive alternatives

Root Insurance

Root Insurance Company

Root Insurance is a mobile-first auto insurer that uses telematics and driving behavior to help determine eligibility and premiums. It is aimed...

Pros

Telematics can reward safer driving more directly than traditional insurers
Fully digital quoting, policy management, and claims handling
Can be competitive for some low-mileage or safe drivers

Cons

Availability and coverage options are more limited than at national insurers
Driving monitoring may be unsuitable for privacy-conscious customers
Rates can be less competitive for drivers with poor or inconsistent driving data

Quote-based; premiums vary by driver and location

Alternatives to Root Insurance → Visit site

Foremost

Foremost is a data recovery software that specializes in recovering lost files from various types of storage media.

Starting from $49.99

Alternatives to Foremost → Visit site

Lemonade

Lemonade is a digital insurance company offering products such as renters, homeowners, life, pet, and auto insurance in eligible markets. It stands...

Pros

Provides a polished mobile experience for buying and managing coverage
Supports several personal insurance categories under one brand
Claims and policy servicing are handled digitally through the app

Cons

Offers coverage from one insurer rather than comparing the market
Availability and product selection vary substantially by location
Not a neutral organizer for policies held with other carriers

Quote-based

Alternatives to Lemonade → Visit site

Trov

Trov is a platform that offers on-demand insurance for individual items.

Varies

Alternatives to Trov → Visit site

VOOM Insurance

VOOM Insurance provides usage-based motorcycle insurance, charging riders based partly on how much they ride. It is designed for low-mileage motorcyclists seeking...

Pros

Mileage-based model can suit riders who use motorcycles infrequently
Digital enrollment and policy management reduce traditional agent interaction
Motorcycle-focused coverage and pricing

Cons

Availability and coverage options vary by state
Less suitable for high-mileage riders than conventional motorcycle policies
Smaller insurer with a narrower product range than major carriers

Quote-based; usage-based pricing

Alternatives to VOOM Insurance → Visit site

GEICO

GEICO provides motorcycle insurance with online quotes, standard liability protection, and optional comprehensive and collision coverage. It targets everyday riders who want...

Pros

National brand with convenient online quoting
Multi-policy discounts can lower costs for existing GEICO customers
Suitable for standard motorcycles and frequent riders

Cons

Does not center its motorcycle pricing on per-mile usage like VOOM
Coverage availability and underwriting vary by state
Fewer usage-based advantages for occasional riders

Quote-based

Alternatives to GEICO → Visit site

How good are these alternatives?

Your feedback helps us improve the AI rankings.

✅ Thanks for your feedback!

Know a better alternative? 🙌

Suggest a product and our AI will verify it's a real alternative to Progressive before adding it to the list.

People also compare

🔎 Dairyland 🔎 Harley-Davidson Insurance 🔎 Allstate 🔎 State Farm 🔎 Nationwide