Best Red Herring Games Alternatives ranked by AI · updated Sep 2026

Red Herring Games produces murder-mystery party games for home hosts, workplaces, and organized events. Its downloadable and hosted formats emphasize character roleplay, themed stories, and adaptable group sizes.

Developer: Red Herring Games Price: From about £24.99 per game 🎯 red-herring-games.com

📅 Event Planning Party Games Roleplay murder mystery

Top 6 Red Herring Games alternatives

You Dunnit

You Dunnit is an online murder-mystery party platform for groups that want to host interactive detective games. It distributes character information and...

Pros

Designed specifically for group murder-mystery play
Digital clue delivery reduces printing and preparation
Works well for remote or in-person gatherings

Cons

Smaller catalog than established murder-mystery publishers
Less suitable for groups seeking fully scripted live theater
Pricing and game availability are not clearly documented

N/A

Alternatives to You Dunnit → Visit site

GooseChase

GooseChase Adventures Inc.

GooseChase is a mobile scavenger-hunt platform for creating missions, collecting photo and video evidence, and tracking participant progress. It serves schools, companies,...

Pros

Stronger team, mission, and event-management features than WallaMe
Supports photo, video, text, and GPS-based submissions
Useful for moderated group activities and competitions

Cons

Focused on organized hunts rather than persistent public messages
No comparable AR camera-overlay placement
Paid tiers can be costly for larger events

Free plan; paid plans from $59/mo

Alternatives to GooseChase → Visit site

My Mystery Party

My Mystery Party publishes murder-mystery games for hosts organizing private parties, corporate events, and themed gatherings. Its catalog includes downloadable and boxed...

Pros

Much larger catalog than You Dunnit
Detailed scripts and printable materials support first-time hosts
Offers games for children, adults, and corporate groups

Cons

More printing and preparation than a digital-first platform
Many games require a host to manage materials manually
Less streamlined for fully remote play

From about $24.95 per game

Alternatives to My Mystery Party → Visit site

Night of Mystery

Night of Mystery creates themed murder-mystery party kits for adult celebrations, corporate events, and holiday gatherings. Each kit provides character backgrounds, clues,...

Pros

Strong selection of themed adult mysteries
Clear host instructions and character packets
Well suited to larger in-person parties

Cons

Typically requires substantial printing and setup
Less flexible than improvisational mystery formats
Remote-play support is less central than in digital platforms

From about $39.95 per game

Alternatives to Night of Mystery → Visit site

Freeform Games

Freeform Games publishes interactive murder-mystery scenarios in which players pursue personal objectives and investigate through conversation. The games are designed for hosts...

Pros

Highly flexible character-driven gameplay
Strong replay value from competing objectives
Works well for experienced roleplaying groups

Cons

Steeper hosting and preparation requirements than You Dunnit
Less suitable for guests who prefer tightly guided play
Most materials are designed for in-person use

From about £19.95 per game

Alternatives to Freeform Games → Visit site

Murder Mystery Party

Murder Mystery Party sells themed murder-mystery kits for hosts running private parties and social events. Its games generally include character information, clues,...

Pros

Accessible format for casual party hosts
Wide selection of themes and settings
Usually includes the core materials needed to run a game

Cons

More dependent on physical or printable materials than You Dunnit
Quality and complexity vary across the catalog
Less suited to players wanting a persistent online experience

From about $24.95 per game

Alternatives to Murder Mystery Par... → Visit site

How good are these alternatives?

Your feedback helps us improve the AI rankings.

✅ Thanks for your feedback!

Know a better alternative? 🙌

Suggest a product and our AI will verify it's a real alternative to Red Herring Games before adding it to the list.