Vinyl Me, Please is a subscription service that delivers exclusive vinyl records to your door each month. It's a great way to...
Pros
- Discover new music
- Curated selections
Cons
- Not fully customizable
Starting at $29/month
Best VNYL Alternatives ranked by AI · updated May 2025
✅ Update queued — the AI is re-ranking this list. The page will refresh shortly.
This page is already up to date.
VNYL is a subscription service that sends you curated vinyl records based on your music taste.
Price: $39/month
🎯 my.vnyl.org
Top 6 VNYL alternatives
Rough Trade Club is a vinyl subscription service that delivers hand-picked records to your door every month.
Pros
- Limited edition releases
- Exclusive discounts on vinyl purchases
Cons
- Monthly subscription fee
- Limited selection compared to other services
$30/month
Vinyl Moon is a unique monthly record club that features custom-designed vinyl records with music from up-and-coming artists.
Pros
- Artistic vinyl designs
- Discover new indie artists
Cons
- Monthly subscription fee
- Limited to custom vinyl releases
$30/month
4
Vinylify allows you to create custom vinyl records with your own music selection. It's a unique way to personalize your music collection...
Starting at $55
Magnolia Record Club is a monthly vinyl subscription that sends members a carefully selected record, often including exclusive pressings. It is aimed...
Pros
- Curated selections reduce the effort of finding new records
- Often features exclusive or limited vinyl pressings
- More independent and discovery-focused than mainstream music subscriptions
Cons
- Members cannot generally choose every monthly title
- Costs more per album than buying used records
- Selection may not match listeners with narrow genre preferences
From $29.95/month
6
Secretly Society
Secretly Group
Secretly Society is a subscription program from Secretly Group that delivers curated releases from its family of independent labels. It is aimed...
Pros
- Direct access to releases from respected independent labels
- Stronger label exclusivity than Magnolia Record Club
- Well suited to fans of experimental and alternative music
Cons
- Narrower catalog scope than broad record clubs
- Less suitable for listeners outside Secretly Group's genres
- Ships less frequently than Magnolia Record Club
From $75/quarter
How good are these alternatives?
Your feedback helps us improve the AI rankings.
✅ Thanks for your feedback!
Know a better alternative? 🙌
Suggest a product and our AI will verify it's a real alternative to VNYL before adding it to the list.