Best Starfish EARLY ALERT Alternatives ranked by AI · updated Aug 2026

Starfish is a higher education student success platform for coordinating advising, referrals, academic support, and early alerts. It helps institutions identify at-risk students and connect them with instructors, advisors, and campus services.

Developer: EAB Price: N/A 🎯 viterbo.edu/advising-and-career-development/starfish-early-alert

Higher Education student success academic advising early alert

Top 6 Starfish EARLY ALERT alternatives

Navigate

EAB

💡 Pick it for a broader student lifecycle platform with predictive analytics and coordinated advising.

Navigate is a higher education student success and advising platform for supporting students from enrollment through graduation. It combines predictive analytics, appointments,...

Pros

Provides broader student lifecycle coverage than Starfish
Combines predictive analytics with advising and outreach workflows
Strong fit for institutions standardizing advising at scale

Cons

Broader scope can require more implementation than a focused early-alert system
Enterprise pricing is not publicly disclosed
May overlap with existing EAB products and institutional systems

N/A

Alternatives to Navigate → Visit site

Watermark Student Success & Engagement

Watermark

💡 Choose it for structured case management and cross-campus intervention tracking.

Watermark Student Success & Engagement helps colleges manage advising, case management, referrals, and student engagement data. It is designed for institutions that...

Pros

Strong case-management and referral workflows for student support teams
Supports coordinated advising across departments
Provides more specialized student-success functionality than a general CRM

Cons

Pricing is quote-based and implementation can be substantial
Analytics may require careful data integration and configuration
Interface and workflows can feel complex for smaller teams

N/A

Alternatives to Watermark Student... → Visit site

Civitas Learning

💡 Pick it when predictive analytics and retention modeling matter more than detailed referral workflows.

Civitas Learning provides data and analytics tools for colleges focused on student success, persistence, and completion. Its platform helps institutions combine educational...

Pros

Stronger student-data and predictive-analytics focus than Gravyty
Supports institution-wide retention and completion strategies
Can help prioritize advisor and intervention resources

Cons

Less centered on mentoring and constituent relationship programs
Requires reliable institutional data integration to deliver value
Analytics adoption depends on advisor and staff workflows

N/A

Alternatives to Civitas Learning → Visit site

EdSights

💡 Choose it for conversational student outreach and earlier signals from student sentiment.

EdSights is a student-engagement and retention platform that uses text messaging, surveys, and analytics to identify student needs. Colleges use it to...

Pros

Strong text-based student listening and sentiment collection
More focused than Gravyty on detecting retention risks through direct feedback
Supports proactive outreach based on student responses

Cons

Narrower than Gravyty for mentoring, alumni, and fundraising programs
Depends heavily on student response rates
Requires processes for staff to act on identified risks

N/A

Alternatives to EdSights → Visit site

Mainstay

💡 Pick it for automated, mobile-first student engagement and support triage.

Mainstay is a conversational engagement platform for colleges and universities that uses messaging and AI-supported conversations to communicate with students. It supports...